[Xs & Joes #34] Negative Recruiting - Does It Actually Work?
Bob and Mike dive deep into the shadowy world of negative recruiting in college basketball, exploring the tactics, effectiveness, and ethics of programs steering players away from rival schools.
Bob Moats and Mike Wiemuth dive deep into the shadowy world of negative recruiting in college basketball, exploring the tactics, effectiveness, and ethics of programs steering players away from rival schools.
Main Topics
Sports Dead Period & Pacers Reflection
[00:00-15:00]
Bob and Mike discuss the dreaded summer sports lull and reflect on the Indiana Pacers' surprising playoff run. They examine the team's selfless ball movement, Tyrese Haliburton's devastating injury, and what the season meant for bringing fans back to NBA basketball after years away.
Negative Recruiting Parallels to Politics
[15:00-25:00]
Drawing parallels to political campaigning, Bob and Mike establish how negative recruiting works as a persuasion contest. They discuss:
Key differences between political ads and recruiting (multiple "candidates," shadow operations)
The concept of "kamikaze" recruiting to prevent rivals from landing recruits
Strategic timing of when to go negative in recruitment battles
The Intelligence Game
[25:00-35:00]
The conversation turns to how programs gather intelligence on recruits and families. Topics include:
Assistant coaches' extensive networks and relationship-building
Understanding family dynamics and decision-makers
The role of third-party surrogates like AAU coaches
How specific intel can get (down to restaurant preferences)
Variables & Vulnerabilities
[35:00-45:00]
Using a comprehensive list of recruiting factors, they explore how different variables create opportunities for negative recruiting. The discussion covers playing time, facilities, academics, party scene, geography, and more, emphasizing how each recruit's priorities differ dramatically.
The Scott Drew vs. Bob Knight Story
[45:00-55:00]
Bob and Mike recount the legendary bathroom confrontation where Bob Knight cornered Scott Drew over negative recruiting materials. This story illustrates the tensions between established programs and upstart challengers trying to disrupt the recruiting landscape.
Player Compensation Era & IU's Fresh Start
[55:00-End]
The discussion shifts to how NIL has changed recruiting dynamics and examines IU's situation under the new coaching staff. They analyze recent comments about fan expectations and how confident leadership can address external criticism.
The YouTube video is below, and you can listen to the audio wherever podcasts are available
Use these links to subscribe to the podcast:
RSS Feed (to add it to a different podcast player)
Don’t see it somewhere you normally listen to podcasts? Let us know.
If you thoughts or comments about the episode, feel free to comment on YouTube video, comment below, or reach out to Mike (@M_Wiemuth_) and Bob (@BobMoats) on Twitter or in our BHN Discord.